Two days ago, the Government announced some measures to combat the economy slowdown, one of which is to reduce the employees contribution to retirement fund. This will put more disposable income into the consumers hands. The Government hopes that this additional disposable income will be spent on the economy.
However, this move has drawn fierce criticisms from workers and employers. And they are not without merit.
By reducing the amount of contribution to the retirement fund, the tax relief will be reduced and so the employees will be taxed more. This is true if the employee has not maximized his tax relief. The additional tax burden is higher the higher the person’s tax bracket.
Many view the retirement fund as a long-term savings account for the retirement years. By contributing less to the fund, we are saving less for our future.
When announced, this scheme was said to be voluntary. But the EPF has come out to say that everybody is automatically enrolled into this scheme. One can choose to opt-out by going through a formal application process. Many believe that “voluntary” means people who wants to contribute less will opt-in rather than having those who wants to contribute more to opt-out. No doubt the Government opted for this route because many people are too lazy to take action, hence the Government would have more people enrolled into this scheme.
There are some people who will be happy contributing less to the retirement fund. One often cited reason is the rate of return on the fund is low. These individuals believe that they would earn a higher rate of return than the fund. So they would prefer to manage their own money rather than having the fund to manage for them.
Others prefer to have more disposable income to pay for bills. Rising cost of living in the last 6 months have greatly eroded disposable income. The prices of many goods and services that have gone up in tandem with the energy costs increase have not gone down despite the reduction in energy costs now. Many families are finding it difficult to make ends meet and having more disposable income gives them some breather.
Also, some people who are opposed to bailout of companies will choose to contribute less. These people believe that the Government would use the retirement savings of the people to bailout companies.